CA backs local curators despite financial losses, confident pitch balance between bat and ball will improve

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

Cricket Australia (CA) has firmly ruled out increasing its control over Test match pitches, maintaining that local curators remain best suited to prepare wickets, even after a costly Ashes series highlighted concerns over pitch quality.

The issue came into sharp focus last summer when the Perth and Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG) Tests both concluded within two days, leading to an estimated loss of nearly AUD 15 million in revenue. The Boxing Day Test at the MCG, in particular, drew heavy criticism, with CA CEO Todd Greenberg acknowledging that the situation was “bad for business.”

Despite the backlash, CA has decided against adopting a centralized pitch management model. Currently, the board does not dictate pitch conditions but works with experienced consultant Les Burdett, who provides guidance to curators. CA’s expectations include producing wickets that last at least four days while ensuring a fair contest between bat and ball without resulting in dull draws.

CA Head of Operations Peter Roach emphasized that Australia’s diverse climate and soil conditions make centralized control impractical. He noted that unlike countries such as England, New Zealand, or South Africa—where conditions are more uniform—Australia’s venues vary significantly, making local expertise essential.

Roach also pointed out that while the Perth pitch was rated “very good” by the ICC, the MCG surface did not meet expectations, with 20 wickets falling on a green top during the Boxing Day Test. However, he expressed confidence that improvements would be made ahead of future matches, citing the quality of pitches prepared in recent seasons.

Cricket Australia continues to view the variation in pitch characteristics across venues—from west to east and north to south—as a competitive advantage. These differences not only challenge players but also enhance the viewing experience for fans.

While acknowledging that allowing curators creative freedom carries some risk, CA believes its long-term track record in maintaining pitch standards is strong. The board remains committed to working collaboratively with venues to ensure better outcomes in future Test matches without compromising the unique nature of Australian pitches.